I received an email from a WCIer which read as follows:
“I just listened to this phone call on the Ramsey Show and thought it would be fun to hear Jim give a reaction to it on a podcast episode. It’s regarding the advice the hosts gave to a plastic surgeon making $750,000 per year with $600,000 in student loans.”
You can watch the video if you like, but I’ll summarize it. A plastic surgeon has a stay-at-home spouse, two small children, and one on the way; $122,000 in savings; two car leases; and $600,000 in student loans ($500,000 for him and $100,000 for his spouse). He wants to know how much of that cash to keep on hand while trying to pay off his debts.
For those who aren’t aware, the Dave Ramsey Show is not into financial nuance. They basically shovel everybody into the same financial plan they call the “Baby Steps,” which is as follows:
- Build a $1,000 emergency fund.
- Pay off all your debt besides your mortgage.
- Save up a 3-6 month emergency fund.
- Save 15% of your income for retirement.
- Save toward a children’s college fund.
- Pay off your mortgage early.
- Build wealth and give.
You don’t move on to the next step until you complete that one. This caller was technically on “Baby Step 2,” and per Dave Ramsey, all his money should be going toward his debts right now. The answer to the caller’s question was to wait until the baby was born and all was well with mom and the new kid, and then take $121,000 of that cash on hand and use it to start wiping out debt, including the car leases.
The baby steps are a simple formula. You could tell the caller—and particularly his spouse—were a little uncomfortable with only $1,000 on hand. That’s kind of the point, though. You’re supposed to be uncomfortable with all that debt and “irresponsible living.” That discomfort then becomes an incredibly motivating force to start digging your way out of that massive pile of debt.
Are Ramsey’s ‘Baby Steps’ Helpful for Docs?
The hosts did a good job of making sure he had disability and life insurance and of pointing out that his $750,000 income was a heck of a shovel that was capable of wiping out this debt very quickly. They didn’t even tell him he had to live like a resident. They told him to live on $200,000-$250,000. But the interesting thing about the whole call was just how uncomfortable everybody was talking about it all. It was like there was a huge sobering realization that this sort of person, which we discuss all the time here at WCI, even exists with their own unique financial challenges. The baby steps are designed for the average American household, and that $1,000 emergency fund hasn’t been indexed to inflation. Maybe it’s OK for this surgeon to keep $10,000 or even $50,000 on hand while smashing his way through the student loans.
They also didn’t seem to have any idea how much tax this doc was paying. They just asked about his “take-home pay” and did their calculations off of that. Well, when you’re a surgeon making $750,000, income taxes are a big part of your financial life. If I had to pick a number out of thin air for that doc’s income tax burden, it would be about 30%.
$750,000 x 30% = $225,000
That leaves $525,000 for this doc to use to live on and build wealth. If this were a resident planning ahead, I’d tell him to try to live off of $100,000 a year and use that $425,000 to build wealth. Within 2-3 years, the student loans would be gone, and they would be building a nice little nest egg. But this doc didn’t come to me, and he didn’t seem to come to anyone until after there was already a lifestyle established out of training, including two car leases. They’re not crazy luxury cars (a pickup and an SUV), but they’re not super cheap cars either. And a long-term rental (aka a lease) probably wasn’t a great choice either. Now it’s a matter of cutting back on the lifestyle so money can be redirected toward those student loans and other wealth-building activities.
The hosts were also savvy enough to recognize that income is a major factor in this situation. Taking that income from $750,000 to $1 million, for instance, makes this whole process go much faster.
More information here:- Financial Waterfalls for New Residents and Attendings
- 10 Financial Baby Steps for White Coat Investors and How They’ll Help You Reach Financial Freedom More Easily
- Get Out of Debt
Another Way to Get Out of This Debt
Overall, I give the Ramsey hosts 3 1/2 out of 4 stars for their advice to this surgeon. It was mostly pretty good. But it does illustrate the benefit of a community like The White Coat Investor, where this sort of financial situation isn’t unusual at all. In fact, it’s downright normal, certainly within the range of normal.
Like with most financial planning, it all starts with the cash flow and your financial goals. Let’s say this doc starts with the following financial goals:
- Put 20% of income toward retirement
- Pay off student loans within four years
- Buy brand-new, paid-for cars when the leases are up (let’s say in two more years)
- Spend $150,000 per year on lifestyle
Now that defined goals exist, we can start working on that cash flow planning. With a $750,000 income,
- $225,000 in taxes
- $150,000 for retirement savings
- $150,000 for lifestyle
- =$225,000 to use for the student loans and cars
How much money would it take to buy two new cars in two years? A nice pickup can be had for $80,000, and a nice SUV can be had for about the same. So, $160,000. Save up $80,000 per year for each, and in two years, you can have two brand-new cars.
$225,000 – 80,000 = $145,000
Is that enough to wipe out the student loans in four years? Let’s say they’re at 6%.
=PMT(6%,4,-600000,0) = $173,155
No, it’s not enough. You would need another $18,000. You either need to go earn another $18,000 (net), or you need to find $18,000 somewhere else in the plan. You can save less for retirement. You can buy cheaper cars. You can spend less on your lifestyle. But it all has to pencil out, even when you make $750,000 per year. You don’t get a pass on math just because you’re doing something good in your life or because you make $750,000 a year or because you pay a ton of money in taxes.
This surgeon’s question that drove him to call in was, “Do I really have to have such a tiny emergency fund for years until my student loans are paid off?” Well, not really. It doesn’t really matter all that much if they sit on $1,000, $10,000, or $100,000 in cash. What really matters is how much of that $750,000 can be directed toward paying off their debts and other wealth-building activities. That’s where the focus should be.
If it were ME in this situation, we’d be driving two $10,000 paid-for cars, living on $100,000 or less, maxing out available retirement accounts (maybe $80,000), and putting the rest ($345,000ish) toward student loans. They’d be gone in two years. That would be my Live Like A Resident period. Then, I’d bump up my retirement savings substantially and gradually start spending more money on my lifestyle. Since I was living on about $8,000 per month, we’d keep maybe $25,00o in cash, and the rest of that $122,000 this couple now has would go toward debt for a big jump start on the process.
† Bonus includes cash rebates and value of free course. Borrowers who refinance more than $60,000 in student loans using the WCI links will be enrolled in The White Coat Investor’s flagship course, Fire Your Financial Advisor: ATTENDING for free ($799 value). Borrowers will still receive the amazing cash rebates that WCI has negotiated with each lender. Offer valid for loan applications submitted from May 1, 2021 through October 31, 2026. Free course must be claimed within 90 days of loan disbursement. To claim free course enrollment, visit https://www.whitecoatinvestor.com/RefiBonus.
What do you think? What advice would you give this surgeon if he had wandered into the WCI Facebook Group, WCI subreddit, or WCI Forum with this question?