There are five financial activities in our lives and we strive to excel in all of them, including:
- Earning,
- Saving,
- Investing,
- Spending, and
- Giving.
We are also trying to teach our children to excel in each of them. We are proud of the progress they are making, although at times they remind us that they have a long way to go. For example, Whitney learned a great deal this year about earning money working as a lifeguard and even starting a photography business. When she cut back on work to play soccer, she failed to cut back on her spending habits and got to learn some painful lessons about the importance of spending wisely.
Long-time readers know that we have an annual charitable giving meeting with the children each December. This is a habit that we hope will continue long after we are gone. The kids may not yet realize this, but the vast majority of our wealth will not be going to them, although we hope they will be capable of wisely controlling where it does go to do the most good. We think this annual meeting is good training for future responsibility. Before the meeting, Katie and I meet at our monthly “budget meeting” and decide how much we're going to give away to charity. So we know the total as we go in, but we have no idea where the money is going to end up.
Even though our giving is most intensely focused during this giving meeting, we actually give throughout the year. We've always given at least 10% but now give more. We give to our nieces and nephews through 529s. They are offered a 200% match on any earned income they put into the accounts. We donate regularly to our church. We endowed a couple of scholarships this year (more on that in a separate post). We fund a large part of the WCI Scholarship every Summer. We also try to be generous to those around us in other spontaneous ways as opportunities come up. However, the annual giving meeting is special, not just because of the opportunity to identify and support worthwhile charities, but also because of the opportunity to teach our children and pass our values along to them.
While I don't write often about religion on this blog, we view giving wealth away as a very spiritual activity. So as we start the meeting, we typically pray and read some scriptures about giving, generosity, and the poor. Each of us, including the children, share a scripture or two and explain why it has impacted us and motivated us to give. Naturally, that includes our family's favorite verse about giving:
Think of your brethren like unto yourself, and be familiar with all and free with your substance, that they may be rich like unto you. But before you seek for riches, seek ye for the kingdom of God. And after ye have obtained a hope in Christ ye shall obtain riches, if ye seek them; and ye will seek them for the intent to do good—to clothe the naked, and to feed the hungry, and to liberate the captive, and administer relief to the sick and the afflicted.
We use this verse as a guideline to select charities. If the charity doesn't do one of these four things:
- Clothe the naked,
- Feed the hungry,
- Liberate the captive, or
- Administer relief to the sick and afflicted,
then we don't support it.
Then, one at a time, each of us gets to present a charity we have researched to the group. We focus on their mission, their ratings from charity rating organizations like Givewell, Give.org, Charity Navigator, and Charity Watch, and the ways in which they have helped those we know personally. This year we chose to support the following eleven charities.
11 of Our Favorite Charities Worth Supporting
# 1 Rick Hodes via the American Jewish Joint Distribution Center
Podcast listeners know that we had Rick on the podcast in December talking about his work and mission treating those with severe spinal deformities in Ethiopia. They also know that Katie and I offered to match every dollar they donated. (Yes, I checked with Katie before promising that). This charity “relieves the afflicted”. 37% of our charitable donations from this meeting went to the clinical work of Rick Hodes. We encourage you to join us.
# 2 Utah Food Bank
We're serious about feeding the hungry, especially those near us. The Utah Food Bank supports soup kitchens, food pantries, and even mobile food pantries. They can make a dollar go much further than we can when it comes to buying food, so we let them do the shopping and we write the check. Katie is always a big supporter of this one, probably because she knows how I get when I get hangry and doesn't want to live in a world where anyone feels that way! This charity obviously “feeds the hungry”. 20% of our donations went to the Utah Food Bank. We encourage you to join us in supporting your local food bank.
# 3 The Road Home
The Road Home runs our local homeless shelters. In Utah, they have a big focus on Housing First in helping those experiencing homelessness, of which we very much approve. Katie presented it this year as one of our “clothe the naked” charities. 8% of our donations went to The Road Home. We encourage you to join us in supporting your local homeless shelters.
# 4 GiveDirectly
I really like this charity, a new one on our list this year. But this one is Afton's pick. She just wanted to give money to poor people. The GiveDirectly folks go to some of the poorest places in the world (and run a similar program in the US) and give people money. That's it. Super simple, but super effective since they know best what their needs are. Then they ask them what they spent the money on. It turns out they usually don't spend it on booze and cigarettes as you might at first imagine. They spend it on medicine, cows, goats, chickens, school fees, water, tin roofs, irrigation, and starting businesses. It's a bit of a stretch, but we consider this one as a “liberating the captive” charity since many of the world's most impoverished are imprisoned by their poverty. 6% of our donations went to GiveDirectly. We encourage you to join us in supporting them.
# 5 Operation Underground Railroad
This one is a perennial favorite charity for us. It always feels like we're supporting Liam Neeson in Taken with this one. You want to talk about “liberating the captive”? That's literally what these guys do. They stop human traffickers and return their victims home. How can you not support that? Maren gets credit for advocating for this charity. 6% of our donations went to Operation Underground Railroad. Please join us.
# 6 Malaria Consortium
Malaria still kills over 400,000 people per year. Every year. Malaria Consortium, among other things, provides malaria prevention meds primarily to children four months a year in high-risk areas. They estimate every $3,000-5,000 saves a life. While it isn't technically relieving the sick, I figure preventing sickness is even better than relieving it. 5% of our donations went to The Malaria Consortium. We encourage you to join us in supporting them.
# 7 Against Malaria Foundation
Can you tell I read The Mosquito: A Human History of Our Deadliest Predator this year? The Against Malaria Foundation primarily provides mosquito nets. They cost about $5 apiece and they estimate they save one life for every $3,000 to $5,000. We couldn't decide whether it was better to give meds or mosquito nets, so we did both. 5% of our donations went to Against Malaria Foundation. Please join us.
# 8 Utah Refugee Connection
We have a lot of refugees in Utah, and this organization helps to give them a fresh start in a new place. We have done some work personally with this organization. Katie gets credit for this one as a “clothe the naked” charity. 4% of our donations went to the Utah Refugee Connection. We encourage you to support your local refugee organizations.
# 9 Disabled American Veterans
Jonas has a soft spot in his heart for veterans and this is the best-rated veterans organization we could find. Our discussion about this one covered everything from military medicine to the role of the Veterans Administration to PTSD. We consider this one a “relieve the afflicted” charity. 3% of our donations went to the Disabled American Veterans. We encourage you to join us in supporting them.
# 10 The Trevor Project
Whitney presented two suicide prevention organizations this year. The Trevor Project has a specific focus on LGBTQ youth. In my work in the ED, I spend a lot of time talking to people feeling suicidal. I know many don't make it that far so I'm happy to support organizations better equipped to make a difference than I can. 3% of our donations went to The Trevor Project. We encourage you to join us in supporting them.
# 11 American Foundation for Suicide Prevention
This organization has a more general focus than The Trevor Project but also works on suicide prevention. Given that physicians are far more likely than the general population to die by suicide, we feel a personal connection to this cause. We view both of these organizations as “relieving the sick” charities. Unfortunately, it appears that a large percentage of their donations are “in memorial” donations. 3% of our donations went to the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention. We encourage you to join us in supporting them.
We now do our giving through a Donor Advised Fund. It provides convenience and enough anonymity to keep our mailbox mostly free of “charity porn”. We don't really keep any money in the DAF so there is little cost for that service. It certainly makes it easier to donate appreciated mutual fund shares to charity.
Giving to charity not only helps us to feel good while supporting worthy causes but reminds us that we are merely stewards of the resources with which we have been blessed. None of the dollars in our bank accounts are going with us when we go. By giving away our hard-earned dollars, we are in effect telling our psyches that “we have enough”. This results in less anxiety about running out of money, less hoarding, and less scrooge-like behavior. I encourage you to incorporate some type of giving program into your life. Done wisely, it can enrich your life and that of others.
What do you think? What are some of your favorite charities? What charities did you support this year and why? Comment below!
Time to up the giving. Thanks for posting this and Merry Christmas.
Thank you! This is a perfect post for the Christmas season.
Inspirational post. To whom much is given, much is expected.
May I ask where the scripture is located?
It’s from the Book of Mormon; Jacob 2.
Thank you.
to whom much is given, much will be required – Luke 12:48
It’s very similar, isn’t it? I think of that concept often.
I am going to take your advice and make contributions to all of these recommended charities today ($100 each), and I am going to challenges the WCI readers to do the same.
Merry Christmas!
Joint distribution center? Nice! …Wait, different type of joints
Thank you for the list and Happy Holidays.
I’d never heard of Operation Underground Railroad before, but they don’t seem to be without controversy.
The Iya Foundation.
This has been helping Dialysis patients in Cameroon where government funding for dialysis treatment is almost zero.
Patients have to pay case to get dialysis and labs.
The founder is a transplant recipient.
Support this Charity if you can and add them to smile on Amazon.com.
Wild. But it’s amazing how far a buck will go in a place like Cameroon.
Thank you for being a role model of success. Anyone who thinks of the White Coat Investor as simply a guide for physicians to accumulate wealth are sorely shortsighted. Merry Christmas to your family and the WCI community.
Thanks for your kind words.
Inspiring, and sans hubris. Thank you WCI.
Thanks for your kind words.
Thanks for posting! Always looking for suggestions on good charities and appreciate that you incorporate this into your family and share with the blog. Cheers and Merry Christmas!
What a wonderful post. Thanks for the inspiring ideas. So timely . God bless
Wonderful post, thank you for sharing. Curious where you stand on environmental protection charities. We are destroying our planet at an alarming pace and I feel strongly that it is our responsibility to help curb this destruction in any way we can, including through charitable giving. I’m finding it difficult to fit environmental charities under one of the 4 categories you listed above, although scripture is replete with verses emphasizing the importance of caring for our environment. I recognize that charitable giving is a personal decision, though I’m interested in your take on this. Thank you and merry Christmas!
Do you have any environmental charities that you give to and could recommend? We lost a family member this year that felt strongly about this cause and we’d like to contribute going forward.
The Access Fund is one of my favorites, but it’s pretty rock climber specific!
These four are highly rated: https://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=content.view&cpid=6891
I am a big fan of the Arbor Day Foundation. I have been donating to them for years. You can even purchase trees in celebration or memoriam and have a card sent to the family.
https://www.arborday.org/
From their website: “We inspire people to plant, nurture, and celebrate trees.
Founded in 1972 — the centennial of the first Arbor Day observance — the Arbor Day Foundation is the largest 501(c)3 nonprofit membership organization dedicated to planting trees. More than 1 million members, supporters, and valued partners have helped us plant more than 350 million trees in neighborhoods, communities, cities, and forests throughout the world to ensure a greener and healthier future for everyone.
Our vision is to help others understand and use trees as a solution to many of the global issues we face today, including air quality, water quality, a changing climate, deforestation, poverty, and hunger.
The impact we make on our world is accomplished through our conservation and education programs. We work to restore forests, improve tree cover in communities, and inspire the next generation of tree planters to ensure this important work endures.”
Certainly a good cause. The fun part about charitable giving is that it is a personal decision. You get to choose what is most important to you and support it via whatever organization you like best. You don’t have to give at all, you can give a little, you can give a lot. You can support one organization one year and a different one the next year.
Some good options here for general environmentalism: https://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=content.view&cpid=6891
Also consider donating to a local land trust to buy and preserve open land – this is what we do in our community (https://mohawkhudson.org/). To search nationally landtrustalliance.org has info. Though in my mind, this is not quite the same as my understanding of “charity” or the Jewish concept of “tzedukah”, it is generally still tax-deductible.
Yes, you can donate to almost anything but politicians and take a deduction for it! The IRS definition of charity is quite broad.
There are some limitations and they are outlined in IRS Publication 526:
https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p526.pdf
There are two broad categories that you have to be careful with.
First, in general, if you give to a foreign charity, it is generally non deductible. However, some contributions to certain Canadian, Mexican, and Israeli charities are deductible. Also contributions to US charities like the Red Cross that are targeted for overseas relief are also deductible.
Second, you have to consider whether you receive some benefit from that contribution to a non-profit organization. For example, a donation to the University of Wyoming would be deductible; however, a contribution that gets you season athletic tickets is not. A contribution to the 4-H organization would be deductible; buying a 4-H steer at the county fair would not be. Also, contributing to a religious school would generally be deductible. However, if that is made for your child’s tuition, it would not be. (These specific examples come from past experiences of many of my CPA colleagues have come across.)
I agree with all that.
Excellent post and I would support almost everything here. However I would encourage doing some more research about OUR. Unfortunately these days you need to be very careful about any group talking about ‘pedophiles’ or ‘sex trafficking’. There are better options out there.
Your suggestions?
My favorite is SMILE TRAIN. Docs go around the world repairing cleft palates. Check their web site. Inspiring. Don D
There are a lot of great charities but I like to keep >75% of my donations in state, if not in my own city. Just makes more sense to support my neighbors.
There are two things that I like about the approach. It is methodical and I think that it is critical to involve your children in the process. You would not believe the number of college students who cannot name one single charity by name.
Our priorities are anti-poverty (especially those serving senior citizens), senior services, and elementary education.
Our charities include:
The Salvation Army – operates the largest shelter in town as well as provides school supplies to students
Friends in Deed – lends medical equipment to area residents without charge and provides senior transportation
Little Sisters of the Poor – provides assisted living and nursing home services to the poor.
Borderlands Food Bank – distributes tons of salvaged produce to food banks in the west and in the Nogales, AZ/MX area.
Catholic Tuition Support Organization – provides scholarships to poor elementary and secondary students in the Tucson area.
I am sure that someone will take some offense to one or more of these organizations BUT they can contribute THEIR money to whatever organization of THEIR choice.
Jim,
We are so happy to say that our family adopted this family tradition directly from you and your family! We adopted the DAF approach from our pal PoF.:)
We have expanded our giving to giving the gift of giving away our “giving savings” in our DAF to family and friends to support their favorite charities. This is our way of generating anti consumption impact giving.
Thank you for helping us organize and expand our approach to giving so that it has an innate generational legacy.
Ooooh….that’s a good idea to let those you care about give away some of your money. I may steal that one.
Congrats on paying off your mortgage too by the way.