Natural Disaster Preparedness — How to Ensure Your Homeowners Insurance Covers the Unexpected

In 2024, natural disasters caused a massive $182.7 billion in damage across the United States, the fourth-highest total on record. As floods, wildfires, hurricanes, and severe storms grow more frequent and intense, the need for true disaster preparedness has never been greater.

One WCI follower on The White Coat Investor subreddit voiced a concern that echoes a growing sentiment among homeowners and future buyers: What if insurance companies start excluding the very events we’re trying to protect against? With some risks, like flood damage, already omitted from standard policies and climate pressures mounting, it’s a question more people are beginning to ask.

The truth is, standard homeowners insurance coverage often isn't enough. To be fully protected, homeowners need to understand their risks and consider additional layers of disaster protection before the next storm hits.

The Increasing Risk of Natural Disasters and What It Means for Homeowners Insurance

In January 2025, Southern California experienced one of its most devastating wildfire events in history. The Palisades Fire alone destroyed over 6,800 structures, claimed 12 lives, and forced the evacuation of more than 100,000 residents.. The total economic impact of these wildfires is estimated to exceed $50 billion, and insured losses were projected to surpass $20 billion, setting a new record for wildfire-related insurance claims in the US.

The growing impact of natural disasters, combined with population growth in high-risk areas, is contributing to a noticeable rise in property damage and insurance claims. As wildfires, floods, hurricanes, and other severe weather events affect more communities, homeowners are increasingly exposed to the risk of significant property and financial loss.

Understanding Your Coverage

Standard homeowners insurance policies typically cover damages from perils like fire, windstorms, and hail. However, they often exclude or limit coverage for disasters such as:​

• Floods: Generally not covered; requires separate flood insurance policies.
• Earthquakes: Typically excluded; buy additional earthquake insurance.
• Hurricanes: Typically included, but in hurricane-prone states, wind and hail coverage may come with a separate, higher deductible.
• Wildfires: In high-risk areas, some insurers are reducing coverage or declining to renew policies altogether.

Homeowners should take steps to protect their property with comprehensive coverage. This includes reviewing current insurance policies, considering supplemental coverage like flood or earthquake insurance, and staying informed about local risks. Proactively addressing coverage gaps can help prevent significant financial loss.

More information here:

What Happens If You Can’t Get Homeowner’s Insurance in Your State?

How Much Homeowners Insurance Do I Need?

Essential Insurance Add-Ons and Policy Riders

Even comprehensive homeowners insurance has its limits. To truly protect your home against major natural disasters, most homeowners will need to explore add-on coverage or separate policy riders. Here's what you need to know and how these policies and add-ons work.

Flood Insurance

A standard homeowners policy does not include flood damage. To get a flood insurance policy, most providers, including Farmer’s Choice, offer coverage through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP). However, this coverage can’t typically be quoted online. Homeowners must contact the insurer directly to obtain a quote and ensure it meets the specific flood risk of their property.

• Average cost: Approximately $900 and possibly more per year through the NFIP.
• Factors influencing cost: Location (especially flood-prone areas), elevation, and the home's construction.

Earthquake Protection

Earthquake damage is also excluded from most standard policies. Some insurers allow homeowners to add earthquake protection as an optional endorsement, depending on the state. This rider provides critical protection in seismically active regions, but it must be discussed and added through an agent. You’ll need to call in for this as well, because online quotes are not available.

• Average cost: Ranges from $300-$1,300 annually or more, depending on location and home characteristics.
• High-risk areas: In states like California, premiums can be higher due to increased seismic activity.

Hurricane Damage Coverage

While there is no standalone “hurricane insurance,” coverage for hurricane-related damage typically falls under wind and hail provisions in a homeowners policy. In hurricane-prone states, this coverage often comes with a separate, higher deductible. As Farmer’s Choice notes, understanding how this applies to your specific location is important, and it’s best discussed directly with an agent to ensure clarity and appropriate limits. Call in for this as well.

• Average cost: Varies widely. For example, the average cost of homeowners insurance in Florida in 2024 is $8,770. This figure surpasses the national average of $2,423.
• Coverage details: While standard policies may cover wind damage, additional windstorm or hurricane-specific coverage might be necessary in high-risk coastal areas.

Wildfire Coverage

As a reminder, fire damage is typically included in standard homeowners insurance policies, so a separate endorsement is not required. But in high-risk fire zones—such as parts of California—insurers may increase premiums; impose higher deductibles; or, in some cases, choose not to renew policies. It’s crucial for homeowners in wildfire-prone areas to confirm coverage limits, understand policy exclusions (like landscaping or outbuildings), and consider additional protection if needed.

More information here:

I Hadn’t Shopped for Insurance in Decades — Could I Have Been Saving Thousands Every Year?

How to Reduce Homeowners Insurance Costs Without Sacrificing Coverage

Disaster Preparedness: Steps to Protect Your Home and Finances

Being proactive can protect both your home and your wallet. Here's how to prepare:

• Create a home inventory: Make it easier using apps on a phone to document belongings. A digital home inventory for insurance makes claims faster and easier.
• Strengthen your home: Consider retrofitting for earthquakes, adding storm shutters, or installing fire-resistant materials. These upgrades can reduce damage and may lower premiums.
• Emergency kit and plan: Pack essentials (food, water, meds, documents) and map out an evacuation route. We keep backpacks in our home filled with essentials in case we need to leave quickly.
• Filing an insurance claim: Take photos of damage, file quickly, and submit your inventory. Knowing the insurance claims process helps you get paid faster.

The Bottom Line

As natural disasters continue to increase in both frequency and financial impact, one thing is clear: standard homeowners insurance often isn’t enough. For WCI followers and other high-income professionals, protecting your assets means going beyond default coverage. Whether it's securing a flood insurance policy, adding earthquake protection, or understanding hurricane damage coverage, many of these provisions require more than an online quote; they require a conversation.

What have you done to ensure your home is insured against natural disasters? Are you more worried about it these days?

 

The White Coat Investor may receive compensation from White Coat Insurance Services, LLC; licensed in all states including MA and DC; CA license #6009217; NY license #1758759 (exp. 6/2025); Registered address: 10610 S. Jordan Gateway, #200 South Jordan, UT 84095. This does not affect the cost or coverage of insurance.