I heard a call on The Dave Ramsey Show from the wife of a soon-to-graduate dental student. She was asking about whether he should use a doctor loan to buy a house. Here are the two segments in case you missed it:
I thought the call was illustrative of two things.
First, the call demonstrated the unbelievable burning desire of graduating docs, and especially their spouses, to buy a house. I’ve discussed this many times before and regular readers know how I feel about buying a house right away (i.e., don’t, especially if you still have years of training ahead of you).
Second, the call illustrated just how debt-numb most doctors are at the completion of their training, as discussed in this guest post by a “profligate borrower.” You see, Dave quickly asked this lady the key questions—“How much student loan debt?” and “How much income?” The answers were not particularly surprising to someone like me who has a pretty good feel for the pulse of the current professional educational environment, but it apparently was to Dave. She said “$480,000 in debt and $120,000 in income.”
The problem here may not be obvious to someone who has not had to deal with a significant student loan burden. To those who have, the issue is very clear. You see, you cannot actually pay off that loan with that income during a normal career length. Let me demonstrate.
Doing the Math on Student Loan Debt
Consider the amount of interest that accumulates each year on a $480,000 debt burden at, let’s say 7%. It’s about $34,000. Let’s assume this couple is relatively tax savvy and only pays 20% in taxes. That’s $24,000. So, $120,000-$34,000-$24,000= $62,000.
Now, let’s assume this family of four lives relatively frugally on a resident’s salary, $40,000. That leaves $22,000 with which to actually pay down the debt, save for retirement, and save for college. Just for fun, we’ll say half of it, $11,000, goes to debt pay off each year.
How long does it take to pay off $480,000 at $11,000 per year? $480,000/$11,000 per year = 44 years. What? You wanted to have your loans paid off before you’re eligible for Social Security? Not going to happen. Not to mention you’re never going to become wealthy when you’re only putting $11,000 a year toward it, and that’s totally ignoring helping the kids with college.
Now, before the critics get after me, I know that it’s not quite as bad as I illustrated. In fact, if you put $45,000 ($34,000 interest and $11,000 principal that first year) toward the 7% debt each year, you actually pay it off in just over 20 years because more of the payment goes toward principal each year. But whether it’s 20 years or 44 years is largely irrelevant in this scenario, because we’re talking about someone who busted his butt in high school to get into a good college, busted his butt in college to get into a good dental school, and then ends up with the equivalent of a resident’s salary for nearly his entire career. Now, I know dentists are really into teeth, but I doubt very many of them are into teeth enough (at least after the first 5 years) to do it for the equivalent of a $40,000/year salary. (Correct me if I’m wrong, dentists.)
The problem is that the debt is just too large for the potential income. Some people look at it as an “investment” of $480,000 to get a job that over a 30-year career will pay $3.2M. As you can see, that’s a very bad way to look at it. Perhaps a better way to look at it is to consider the ratio of student loan debt to peak earning salary.
For example, an internist with the average student loan debt of $200,000 and an income of $200,000 has a ratio of 1x. An orthopedist with a student loan burden of $400,000 and an income of $400,000 also has a ratio of 1x. But a pediatrician with a debt of $450,000 and an income of $150,000 has a 3x ratio, and a dentist with a debt of $480,000 and an income of $120,000 has a 4x ratio.
What Is the Ideal Student Loan Debt-to-Salary Ratio?
What is the ideal ratio? Well, it’s 0x, but that’s the wrong question to ask. The right question is what is the maximum ratio you should tolerate before deciding additional student loan debt just isn’t worth it?
My general debt recommendation is to not exceed a 1x level for your student loans and a 2x level for your mortgage. Obviously, people in the Bay Area often have to stretch that recommendation to get a home. But when I say stretch I’m talking 3x-4x. And that stretch is going to have a significant effect on minimum career length, vehicle driven, school attended, etc. Likewise, perhaps some physicians and dentists attending an expensive school without parental or spousal support have to stretch a bit. But when I say stretch, I’m talking maybe 2x, not 3x-4x. And again, that’s going to have a significant effect on lifestyle.
I think most docs should aim to have their student loan burden gone within 5 years of the completion of training. What percentage of income must go toward student loans to accomplish this? Let’s take a look.
Let’s assume an interest rate of 7%.
- 1x: 24% of gross income
- 2x: 48% of gross income
- 3x: 72% of gross income
- 4x: 96% of gross income
Basically, 3x-4x is impossible. So don’t ring up 3x-4x in student loan debt. Either choose a different profession or find someone else (i.e., the military or similar) to pay the bill.
What If You Already Have Too Much Student Loan Debt?
Unfortunately, this is the real question. There are tens of thousands of docs who are either in this situation or soon will be. What can they do? Well, there are a few options to consider.
#1 Boost Income
What if that dentist figured out a way to make $250,000 instead of $120,000? Now his ratio is less than 2x. How can he do that? He can go to an area with more demand, he can work harder, or he can learn a thing or two about business and own the practice, bringing in some associates and keeping part of what they generate. He can also take a second job, such as real estate investing or another entrepreneurial pursuit.
#2 Find a 501(c)(3) Job and Go for PSLF
There aren’t nearly as many of these for dentists as for physicians, but they do exist. Even if the job pays 25% less, it also means your loans are gone in less than a decade.
#3 Go for IDR Forgiveness
This isn’t a great option since it takes 20-25 years and the forgiveness is taxable, but when you’re desperate, you’re desperate.
#4 Get a Partner, Especially a High-Earning One
There are many doctor couples I have run into where one of them is either not working at all or barely working. That’s fine. It’s not tough to live on a single doctor's salary—I’ve done it for years. But in this situation, the family isn’t living on anywhere near a doctor's salary. So if your spouse has the ability to earn, especially earn a lot, send them to work. You simply cannot afford the luxury of a stay at home spouse given your previous financial errors.
I almost put a #5 live really frugally, but that’s pretty much a given. You don’t even really have the option to do otherwise, and you can only squeeze so much blood from a turnip. Clipping coupons and reusing paper towels isn’t going to do a lot when it’s up against a debt churning out $30,000+ a year in interest.
If you’re in this situation, I’m sorry. If you’re not yet in this situation but heading that way—do all you can to minimize your student loan burden and maximize your income. It might seem like monopoly money now, but I assure you the bill will come due eventually.
What do you think? What is the maximum acceptable ratio of student loan debt to income? What is the best way to deal with it if you find yourself already in this situation?
Variable 5.04%-9.05% APR
† Bonus includes cash rebates and value of free course. Borrowers who refinance more than $60,000 in student loans using the WCI links will be enrolled in The White Coat Investor’s flagship course, Fire Your Financial Advisor: ATTENDING for free ($799 value). Borrowers will still receive the amazing cash rebates that WCI has negotiated with each lender. Offer valid for loan applications submitted from May 1, 2021 through April 30, 2026. Free course must be claimed within 90 days of loan disbursement. To claim free course enrollment, visit https://www.whitecoatinvestor.com/RefiBonus.