Irrevocable trusts are primarily estate planning and asset protection tools. Unlike a revocable living trust, where assets can generally be moved in and out, assets transferred to an irrevocable trust typically cannot simply be taken back. That loss of ownership and control is what creates many of the benefits. Assets placed in the trust, along with their future appreciation and income, may be removed from the grantor’s taxable estate. This can be particularly valuable for people with estates large enough to face estate taxes or who own rapidly appreciating or income-producing assets they do not expect to need during their lifetime. Because the assets belong to the trust rather than the individual, they may also receive protection from creditors. However, assets generally must be transferred well before a lawsuit or creditor problem arises. Moving assets after a claim exists may be considered a fraudulent transfer.
The tradeoff for those benefits is giving up significant control and access to the assets. In most irrevocable trusts, the same person cannot simultaneously be the grantor, trustee, and beneficiary and still receive meaningful asset protection. Some states allow domestic asset protection trusts that permit the grantor to also be a beneficiary, although there is uncertainty about how well these structures will hold up in every situation. Another strategy is a spousal lifetime access trust, or SLAT, where one spouse establishes the trust and the other spouse is the beneficiary. This can provide estate tax and asset protection benefits while allowing the household to retain some indirect access to the money. Some couples establish a SLAT for each spouse, but the trusts should not be identical and generally should be created at different times to avoid running afoul of rules governing reciprocal trusts.
Charitable trusts are another important type of irrevocable trust, particularly for people who already have charitable intentions. Charitable lead trusts and charitable remainder trusts divide the benefits between a charity and another beneficiary, such as the donor or an heir. A charitable remainder trust, for example, can provide income to a beneficiary for a specified period before the remaining assets pass to charity. This can be especially useful when selling a highly appreciated asset such as a business. These strategies can provide substantial tax and estate planning benefits, but they also come with complexity, administrative requirements, trustee responsibilities, investment management costs, and potentially significant professional fees. For many people, those costs and hassles will outweigh the benefits. Irrevocable trusts tend to make the most sense when there is a clear estate tax, asset protection, or charitable planning need substantial enough to justify the additional complexity.
This is the White Coat Investor Podcast: Financial Bootcamp, your fast track to financial success.
Dr. Jim Dahle:
Irrevocable trusts can be useful both in estate planning and in asset protection. Irrevocable means when you put assets in it, when you gift assets to the trust or sell assets to the trust, you can’t take them back out. That’s different from a revocable or a living trust, where you can take assets in and out anytime you like.
The main purpose of a revocable trust is just to avoid probate, which can be expensive, which can be time-consuming, which is a public process, often worth avoiding by using a revocable trust. But you don’t need an irrevocable trust to avoid probate.
Irrevocable trusts are generally used to reduce your estate taxes or for asset protection purposes. Because it’s no longer your money, you can’t take it back. It belongs to the trust. It’s outside your estate, and so you will no longer owe estate taxes on the value of that asset when you die, nor any earnings it makes or any increase in value it has from the time you put it in the irrevocable trust until your death.
So that’s why people use it to reduce estate taxes. They have something that’s appreciating rapidly or that produces a lot of income. They want it outside their estate, and they figure they’re probably not even going to need to spend it during their lifetime. So they put it in an irrevocable trust. They figure it’s going to a charity or their heirs or whatever when they die, and so they get it out of their estate, put it in the irrevocable trust, and then any increase in its value over time does not go against their exemptions for estate tax purposes when they die.
The other benefit of having something owned by a trust and not by you is if you get sued, they can’t take the stuff that’s in the trust. Now, it can’t be a fraudulent transfer. You can’t wait until you hurt somebody or until they file suit against you and then move all your stuff into an irrevocable trust. It doesn’t work that way. That’s a fraudulent transfer. You have to do it in advance.
But the truth is, once it’s been in there a certain amount of time in a given state, your creditors cannot get it back out of that trust. It doesn’t belong to you. You could declare bankruptcy. It doesn’t affect that trust whatsoever. And so those are the main reasons that a physician or other high-income professional or a high-net-worth person would consider an irrevocable trust: estate planning purposes and asset protection purposes.
Obviously, it also helps make sure your things go to where you want them to go in a non-public, rapid way after death. It’s not going through probate, so there are these estate planning benefits associated with it. But for the most part, it’s a tax play. It’s an asset protection play.
So, what do you give up when you put assets into an irrevocable trust? You give up some control unless you’re one of the trustees of that trust, and you certainly give up the ability to bring it back out of the trust and use it for your own benefit. Most irrevocable trusts, you can’t be the trustee and the grantor, the person who funds the trust, and the beneficiary. That’s just not the way they work. It doesn’t provide any asset protection benefits if those three things are all the same person.
That is not the case in some states, though. Some states have decided we want people to be able to do that, and those are called domestic asset protection trusts, where you literally can be the beneficiary of the trust that you are the grantor for. And there’s some uncertainty as to how well these work in a true above-policy-limits judgment asset protection situation, but it’s probably better than nothing.
It probably does help protect your assets in at least some situations, especially if it’s been in there for a long time and if you followed all the regulations of your state, and if the lawsuit’s in your state, and you’re still in the state, and the assets are in your state, then it’s probably going to work. Just recognize there’s some uncertainty there. There are other ways that people try to get around this issue.
They want the asset protection benefits. They want the estate tax benefits of having money in an irrevocable trust, but they kind of still want to use some of the money, or at least want the option to use some of the money if they have to.
One of the things that people have come up with in this sort of a situation is a type of intentionally defective grantor trust, an IDGT, they’re often called, and one type of those is a SLAT. The SLAT stands for a spousal lifetime access trust. So it’s very interesting. The grantor is one spouse. The beneficiary is the other spouse. So they’re not the same person. So that’s fine, right? So it gives you some estate tax benefits. It gives you some asset protection, etc. But assuming you’re on pretty good terms with your spouse, they’re going to share those benefits from the trust with you.
So some people set up just one of these, with just one spouse being the beneficiary. Some people set up two different trusts, one where each spouse is the grantor and the other spouse is the beneficiary. Recognize that those trusts can’t be exactly the same. It’s probably best if their terms are slightly different and they’re started at slightly different times, or they might be outlawed in an asset protection kind of situation.
Another type of irrevocable trust that’s worth knowing about is a charitable trust. There’s basically four main types of these. There are lead trusts and remainder trusts, and in each of those types, there are unitrusts and there are annuity trusts.
A lead trust means the charity. These are all split-interest gifts between the charity and somebody else. Somebody else might be you or one of your heirs. But in a lead trust, the charity gets the money and then pays some type of a benefit to a beneficiary for a certain number of years or until they die. With the remainder trust, the trust pays the beneficiary some amount each year until they die, or for five or 10 or 20 years, and then the charity gets whatever’s left. So the lead or the remainder refers to the charity.
With a unitrust, it’s more about what the trust is earning as it goes along and how much is paid out. On an annuity trust, that amount is somewhat fixed. And so for some people, for estate planning purposes, it can make a lot of sense to use something like a charitable remainder unitrust.
Particularly if they’re selling a business and they’d have to pay a lot of taxes on the sale of that business, they might move it into a charitable remainder unitrust and then have it pay them an income for 20 years, if they want it to, and then the remainder goes to charity. It doesn’t make sense to set these things up unless you have some charitable intentions anyway. But if you do, there are some significant tax benefits available for using those types of trusts.
Now, one thing to be aware of is you have to follow the rules with these trusts. If you are the trustee, you’ve got to do the things that you’re required to do as a trustee. If you’re going to hire a professional trustee, you’ve got to pay for that. You might have to pay somebody to manage the assets inside the trust, and so they can be expensive, and there’s certainly some significant hassle associated with having two entities. It’s not just you. It’s you and a trust, maybe multiple trusts.
And so you need to ask yourself: Is this complexity worth it? Are the benefits I’m getting for this worth it to me in order to reduce my estate tax or to have some asset protection in the very unlikely situation that I’m the recipient of an above-policy-limits judgment? And for a lot of people, the answer is going to be no, that it isn’t worth it. But if it is, make sure you understand how it works. Try to minimize those costs and that hassle, and go ahead and move forward. Hope that helps you understand what irrevocable trusts can be used for.
DISCLAIMER
The White Coat Investor Podcast is for your entertainment and information only and should not be considered financial, legal, tax, or investment advice. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. You should consult the appropriate professional for specific advice relating to your situation.
Medical school may not have taught you about money, but we will.
We will never sell your information. Modify your preferences or unsubscribe at any time.
Get ready to take control of your financial life. You can do this, and we can help.
We won't sell your information. Modify your preferences or unsubscribe at any time.