Here's a question I've been asked before:
“I know you have recommended that attending physicians should be putting about 20% of their gross income toward retirement. My spouse and I have found this to be very difficult, both early on and now that we’re in our mid-careers. I am a bit embarrassed to say this, but I don’t see how we could spend much less than we currently do without a dramatic change in our lifestyle. What should we do?”
The Hedonic Treadmill
Just as the time required to perform a chore seems to expand into the time available, our spending naturally expands until it consumes our entire income. For most people, it requires a conscious and sometimes difficult effort to avoid this process. It is also a truism of personal finance that decreasing spending is far more psychologically painful than increasing spending is pleasurable. To make matters worse, many of us find ourselves on the “hedonic treadmill,” aka “hedonic adaptation.”
As you make more money, your expectations and desires rise in tandem, resulting in no permanent gain in happiness. Thus, you work harder and harder, spending more and more, and then you find you are no happier making and spending $500,000 a year than you were making and spending $100,000 a year. To make matters worse, the increasingly progressive tax burden on that additional income can further destabilize your finances.
More information here:
Lifestyle Inflation and Its Impact
Effects of Spending on Financial Independence
(Click for larger image)
Since you can always spend your entire income and then some, the secret to financial independence always lies primarily on the spending side of the equation. As a rule of thumb, financial independence means you have a level of assets that is approximately 25 times your annual spending requirements. The less you spend, the sooner you will become financially independent and the less you will have to save to reach that point—which also means you will need to take less risk with your investments. The easiest way to avoid the hedonic treadmill is to never get on it in the first place. However, for most of us, a conscious effort is required to get off the treadmill or at least limit its effects on our financial lives.
Financial literacy can pay great dividends in this respect. If you have never heard of hedonic adaptation, chances are that you are already on the treadmill. Recognizing this completely natural tendency goes a long way toward fighting it. Understanding the consequences of a low savings rate (i.e., out-of-control spending) is also helpful. Saving more money each year not only increases the size of your nest egg, but it also reduces the size of the nest egg required to maintain the same lifestyle in retirement.
The math behind financial independence is surprisingly simple. You can make a chart with a 0% savings rate at one end and a 100% savings rate at the other. Then, using some simple basic assumptions (i.e., 5% real investment return and a 4% real withdrawal rate) and ignoring the effects of pensions and Social Security, you can determine how long you need to work for any given savings rate.
For example, if you make $200,000 per year and save 50% of your income, you only need your investments to provide $100,000 in income, and you can reach that point after about 16 years. But if you only save 10% of your income, then you need your investments to provide $180,000 of income, and it will require 50 years to reach that point. Obviously, everyone’s financial situation differs, and if someone inherits significant assets early in life, they have the potential to become financially independent much earlier. But whether you start saving and investing at age 20 or 40, it still takes just as long to reach financial independence, and that amount of time is most dependent on your savings rate.
The chart above overstates the case quite a bit, as most retirees will have some Social Security while naturally spending much less in retirement than they did earlier in life—mortgages are paid off, tax burdens decrease, children leave home and finish their educations, work-related expenses disappear, and the need for life and disability insurance is eliminated. And if you work and save until you’re 80, you probably won’t need your portfolio to last as long as an early retiree will.
But the point of the chart remains the same—increased savings simultaneously increases portfolio size and decreases the need for income from the portfolio.
More information here:
The Other Side of Hedonic Adaptation: When Life Knocks You Down
How to Get Off the Hedonic Treadmill
There are some practical steps that can be taken to get off the hedonic treadmill. Everyone has heard about how important it is to live on a budget. What they might not tell you, however, is that living on a budget is really a temporary process. A budget is a training tool, and once you’ve trained yourself to spend at a sensible level, you can actually quit the physical act of budgeting. Most financially successful people can generally get to that point with a few months or years of careful budgeting. Track your spending by initially writing down every dollar you spend; then make sure you are actually spending your money in accordance with your values.
For example, if you find you value vacations with your children and having a nice home the most but you discover you are spending a large percentage of your money on education, eating out, and car payments, you need to realign your spending with your values. As a typical physician, you can generally buy anything you want but not everything you want. Spend your money on what makes you the happiest.
Some people find it easiest to boost their savings rate by “saving their raises.” Every time their income goes up, they simply keep spending the same way they did on a lower income. This technique, however, does not work as well for most emergency physicians, who generally reach peak earnings relatively early in their careers.
Studies have shown that spending cash is psychologically more painful than using a debit card, which, in turn, is more painful than using a credit card. This behavioral tendency, combined with the convenience of cards, means that we generally spend more when using credit cards. If you aren’t saving as much as you would like, consider going to a cash-spending plan.
Psychological studies also show that our willpower is limited. We can deny ourselves only so many times before giving in to temptation. However, it turns out it takes the same amount of willpower to decide not to buy a BMW as to avoid buying a latte. Use your limited willpower where you can get the most bang for your buck—on the big-ticket items.
Recognizing the behavioral pitfalls that lead to out-of-control spending can help keep you off the hedonic treadmill. Practicing emergency medicine is far more enjoyable when you do not have to do it for financial reasons.
Have you found yourself on the hedonic treadmill? Have you been able to reverse it? How? How much do you save and why?
[This updated post was originally published in 2016 after first appearing on ACEP.]