[Editor’s Note: This is a republished post from Physician on FIRE, a member of The White Coat Investor Network. The original post ran here, but if you missed it the first time, it’s new to you! If you've never heard of the Frank Starling Curve of Happiness, this post is for you. Enjoy!]
Welcome to another Top 5 list, the Top 5 Reasons to achieve Financial Independence (FI). I’ll admit, it wasn’t easy whittling this list down to 5.
# 1 Give Yourself Options
Being FI, you’ve got a nest egg that should support you indefinitely. Work becomes optional. That’s right, you can choose how to spend your days.
If you’ve longed for a 3-day workweek, now is the time to make that a reality. If you’ve wanted to do some teaching or research, but had chosen private practice for the better pay, now is the time to explore that academic position. If you’re fed up with the shenanigans of your hospital and governmental administrators, and you’re mad as hell and can’t take this anymore, you don’t have to take it anymore. You can afford to take a sabbatical or walk away for good. By investing in your future, you’ve bought yourself options.
# 2 You Are Now Self-insured
Remember the nice, young gentlemen who bought you dinner during residency and sold you some necessary insurance products? The one who sends you a “Happy Holidays” card every year and sends random e-mails to make sure your insurance needs are being met? You’ve got an unpleasant task ahead, because breaking up is hard to do
.
Disability insurance is a very good idea for any young physician, and if you’ve got a family depending on your income, term life insurance is paramount as well. You need money in case you can’t work due to injury, and your family needs money if you can’t work because you died. Guess what? If you already have enough money to support yourself and your family without a biweekly paycheck, you don’t need to insure against losing that income. I would guesstimate that many physicians spend about $5,000 a year on these insurance premiums. Being FI allows you to put that money to work somewhere else. You could put $5,000 into a child’s 529 fund or donate about $9,000 to your donor advised fund or other charity.
# 3 Start Working For Others
Why strive for financial independence when you have no interest in retiring early? You can keep working of course, but now you can start working for the benefit of other people. You don’t need the money, but there are others that do. By virtue of having a high salary for a number of years, you have been “donating” all along, but the government decided where the money went. Now, you can give your earnings freely to people and projects that are meaningful to you. You may want to help a relative who is struggling. You may want to fund an expansion at the local dog shelter or food shelf. Giving to charity not only lowers your taxes, but it makes you feel good too.
Functional MRI has shown that we like to give, with areas of the brain associated with pleasure lighting up when we choose to give our money to causes we deem worthy. Achieving FI allows you to give more freely and generously, helping others in need while simultaneously boosting your own happiness.
# 4 The Future Is Uncertain
To paraphrase a common saying, “stuff happens”. All kinds of stuff. And some stuff is bad enough to require a leave of absence from your day job. If you are in your forties or fifties, you might have parents in their seventies or eighties. You might even have grandparents, perhaps now in their nineties. All kinds of bad can happen to people at those advanced ages. Wouldn’t it be wonderful to have the ability to leave work behind without worrying about how your bills will be paid?
Badness can befall you too, or a spouse or close friend, or God forbid, one of your children. Financial Independence gives you the irreplaceable ability to be with loved ones in a time of need. Money can’t buy compassion, but it can buy the time you need to show compassion when it’s needed most.
# 5 Evaluate The Relationship Between Your Spending and Happiness
Recall that the key variables in the FI equation are the size of your nest egg and the amount of your annual spending. You are FI when the nest egg has X years of expenses, where X is a number like 25 (or perhaps 33 or 40 if you want to be really safe).
You can get closer to FI by growing your nest egg and/or by decreasing your expenses. Injecting a dose of frugality into your life can help you learn what truly makes you happy. Studies show that happiness pretty much plateaus once the household income hits $50,000 to $75,000. If you’re spending twice that much, you may be squandering a lot of money for very little added enjoyment. I like to think of the spending / happiness ratio in terms of a Frank Starling Curve of Happiness.
Replacing stroke volume (how much volume your heart pumps with each beat) on the Y axis with happiness and Left Ventricular End Diastolic Pressure (blood volume) on the X axis with spending and leaving the overall shape alone gives us a pretty good representation of reality. When we start from 0, we see increasing levels of happiness with each additional dollar of annual spending. Once we reach a level of spending in the $50,000 to $75,000 range, the curve nearly plateaus. Additional spending may give us little boluses of happiness, but they are fleeting. Once our spending approaches or exceeds our take-home pay, we see a decrease in happiness. Call it congestive spending failure. We’re adding stress to our lives by going deeper into debt, not saving for retirement, and living a life that is unsustainable.
What do you think? Are these good enough reasons for you to want to become Financially Independent? What other reasons might be in your Top 5? Do you think the happiness graph really tails off at higher levels of spending? Comment below!
“By virtue of having a high salary for a number of years, you have been “donating” all along, but the government decided where the money went.
Functional MRI has shown that we like to give, with areas of the brain associated with pleasure lighting up when we choose to give our money to causes we deem worthy.”
I don’t think my fMRI would light up when my money is “donated” for me on April 15th.
True. Paying taxes is not equivalent to making an actual donation to the cause of your choice, which is why “donating” appeared in quotes. I do all I can to pay fewer taxes, and actual donations are a big part of that strategy.
Best,
-PoF
without trying to stir up trouble, I wonder whether there are any estimates about how much (percentage-wise) of our overall taxes are squandered every year.
I remember seeing an estimate of how much of Medicare/aid is squandered in fraudulent claims.
One man’s “squander” is another man’s smart purchase. Good luck finding a significant amount of money that everyone agrees is being misspent.
#4 for sure. I was very thankful that I had already achieved FI when my father got cancer 9 years ago. I was able to spend a ton of time with him during his last 18 months. Having that freedom is priceless.
50-75K is maximum happiness?
Well first under aca for middle aged couple plan on 20k after premiums, deductibles, copays for healthcare. You might get by with less, but this is a good number to plan on.
Transportation could easily be another 10 k year (using irs rate to amortize cars, insurance, gas etc)
Then housing even in a modest city is 12000 a year minimum
Utilities including phone, cable, elec, gas etc probably 4-5k per year
You are at 47k without buying any food! Or taking a vacation or two? Or maybe giving a gift or donating to charity? Or some sports tickets or golf rounds?
I can ASSURE you that while 50-75k for a couple is “doable” it does NOT maximize happiness. The number to maximize happiness varies for everyone but for most couples it is WAY more than 50-75K
The graphs of happiness vs income I’ve seen show the slope changing dramatically (downward) in the $50-100K range, but still going upward.
The more money you make, the more you give up in other ways.
Everyone’s priorities are different, and that graph is deceptive in the sense that cost of living varies so widely. In the south east that graph is spot on if not overestimating . In NY City, not so much.
Even though my expenses total about $10k year ($15k at most), very few people manage to keep expenses under $30-50k in my area. Most people base their expenses on their income. NOT how to get ahead.
You may notice that my graph does have increasing happiness beyond $75K, although the rate of rise decreases — you start to see some diminishing returns from those additional dollars spent (according the survey / study).
Also, the $75K was income (equated with spending, but not the same), and I would guess most families have health insurance at least partially covered by an employer, so that does free up some room.
Last year, my family spend $62,000 (http://www.physicianonfire.com/62000-spent-heres-where-it-went/) and lived pretty well, but that includes a number of “cheats” like a paid off home, travel hacking, CME trips combined with vacation, no term life or disability, public schools, etc…
Best,
-PoF
I love that a paid-off home and public schools are a hack.
So if you add 20K for health care, that 75K maximum happiness would be more like 95K for an early retiree without employer-sponsored health insurance who still has a mortgage. Now we’re talking a nest egg of around $3 million for maximum happiness in retirement.
For #5 when you say: “If you’re spending twice that much, you may be squandering a lot of money for very little added enjoyment.” I agree and many people may not be evaluating if that spending is providing a good return of enjoyment. Especially for recurring expenses, paying laser attention to whether spending is providing value is critical.
I will leave this here as I find it a very powerful position. The best reason to become FI.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJjKP8vYjpQ
Exactly what I told my colleagues in the recent past.
There is no better feeling than financial independence, its like a few other things in life which cannot be adequately described.
JL Collins did a mashup of that video, replacing John Goodman in the scenes — you’ll find it with a quick Youtube search.
Cheers!
-PoF
Yup x 5. I want options and the future of medicine is certainly not clear!
I decided to play big boy and leased an Audi A8 last august after drivIng a long paid for Nissan Murano for years. I can easily pay for it, being a partner in a busy practice. However, all this talk of frugality is weighing on my practical side, the side that wants to be a good steward of my money and achieve FI. Suffice it to say, I’m thinking of getting out of this lease.
So Big Boys buy stuff in what is often the most expensive manner possible? I guess we’ll have to agree to disagree about that.
I do like Audi A8s though. Hard to know what the best thing to do with this lease is without running the numbers, but why not just buy your A8 next time?
Actually, I based it off of one of your old posts that advised renting your “big ticket items”. I guess I’ve fallen victim to the stupid tax. I thought for years about this car and was pushed over the edge by the wife saying you deserve something nice and my partners in their Porsche and tesla cars giving my hooptie looks at the partner meetings. All in all, it’s probably my only dumb financial move. To make myself feel better, it was last years model and I got a really good deal on it. Oh well. Live and learn.
I don’t think WCI has ever said you can’t drive a nice/expensive car. My understanding of what he seems to say is that you can’t drive an expensive car, and buy a boat, and a vacation home, and travel to exotic locales every other month, and have a country club membership, and send the kids the private school and still max out retirement accounts and expect to retire early or even on time. And he also seems to say that you shouldn’t do any of those things until
You’ve paid off your student loans and have a good start on your way to FI.
I’m never ever going to have a $50,000 boat, so I splurged and bought an expensive car. Our house is relatively inexpensive compared to my salary, but we do travel a fair amount. It’s all a trade off. I just don’t think he’s ever said we need to live like Benedictine monks for our entire existence either.
Benedictine monk! Nice. I guess I can stop recycling toilet paper now.
The nice thing about a physician level income is we can make lots of financial mistakes and still be okay. Just don’t make too many!