
In the summer of 2022, I visited a friend in Canada. The move from the US had treated their family well, and it made me pause: should I do the same? A year later in the summer of 2023, I pulled a trailer with my electric car across the US to Canada. I was moving. It had happened.
As a US physician moving to Canada, here are a few steps I learned along the way.
The Logistics of Moving to Canada as a Physician
First, I’m assuming you are a medical professional reading this. Even if you’re not, much of what I’ve learned will apply to you anyway. Whoever you are, this is the time to immigrate to Canada. The doors are opened for thousands of immigrants. Many pathways lead forward.
Second, this column is not the why to immigrate. That is your story. Maybe someday we can share it together. In short, I decided to move to Canada for my family.
Lastly, the focus of this column is on immigrating from the US to Canada. There will be overlap for other countries, but I don’t know all that applies. Let’s get going.
Express Entry is a term you should know. It’s a rating system for people who want to immigrate. It’s based on individual details and heavily weighs connections to Canada—having studied, lived, or worked there. I had none of that! It is not related to being a physician and is open to anyone. Every year, Canada draws from this list to accept people to become permanent Canadian residents.
To apply, you need to take a language test. I did mine in San Francisco. My partner and I made a weekend trip of it. It’s a standardized exam like the USMLE (before you get stressed, know it is much easier). It does involve aspects of talking, reading, and writing. I did not study for it, and I scored high. Your test results add to your Express Entry points. Lastly, you need to do a physical examination—physical, chest X-ray, and blood work. I did mine in Seattle; we did it as a family and made a trip to Pikes Market Place (you gotta love the flying fish!).
Express Entry aside, know there are other ways to immigrate—they just take longer. That said, if you get a provincial nomination (a program based on the province’s need for employment), you get 600 points added to your Express Entry application, ensuring you will be picked in the next draw. Now, provincial nominations are a topic for another column but know that they exist. Also know they are not required, and there is more than one kind. But only one type can be added to Express Entry—that type is due to an identified worker shortage, aka physicians. I’m waiting to see if I will get it. But yes, that means you can move before getting one.
More information here:
5 Financial Considerations for American Doctors Wishing to Live Abroad
When Everything Clicks into Place: How Foreign Travel Can Make You a Better Doctor
Getting Licensed in Canada
The location of the US and Canada made me assume a level of professional reciprocity existed between the countries. And it does exist but not to the level I thought. Frankly, it’s easier to get licensed as a psychologist than a physician. My licensing process as a physician took about a year and required me to get a work permit before my medical license. I felt like I was trying to figure out what came first: the chicken or the egg! The process involved touches with many separate governmental bodies; these bodies don’t communicate with each other which caused me to repeat many steps over and over for each individual governmental agency.
First, your credentials are verified by the Canadian Medical Protective Association (CMPA). Then, you can both apply to the National Board Certification process and to the province of your choice. If we think about electrical circuits, the first process is in series and the next two are in parallel.
Know this: for the Royal College (aka the board certification for all but family medicine), there are only specific times a year you can apply. For me, that was in February 2023. It is now October 2023 as I write this, and they are only now finally starting to correspond with me.
Tip: Start this process when you can and don’t expect it to be started and finished quickly. If you need some cash, I recommend an emergency savings fund and/or to keep up a practice in the US during the transition.
Inside advice: You don’t have to be board-certified to be licensed in all of the provinces. Several of the provinces are opening their doors, and they have their own verification process separate from the Royal College.
More inside advice (for pediatricians): in Canada, pediatric residency is four years. This has created a barrier in the past for pediatricians trained in the US without a chief year or fellowship (aka a fourth year). I had only three years of residency and worried about getting licensed due to this. Thankfully, this is changing in some provinces, and I am now licensed. Keep hope!
Also remember that licensure is just that, a license to practice medicine. It is not a work permit. That is separate and needed if you are not a Canadian permanent resident or citizen. There are open and closed work permits. Closed permits are linked to an employer and based on you working for that specific employer. Open permits are (surprise, surprise!) open and allow you to work with any employer. They can have restrictions—no educational study and no work in the sex industry, for example. If your partner gets a work visa, you can get an open work visa through that and don’t need a job prior to moving. You likely can find one on arrival. Know that the need is great for physicians in Canada, and if you have minor children, they can get study permits to go to school with your work permit. It’s a win-win.
Make sure to talk with an immigration lawyer. They can put together your immigration paperwork or at least guide you along the way. If you want to save some money, get the guidance and then do it yourself—that’s what I did. You can also apply ahead of time for a work visa or get one (with the appropriate paperwork) upon entering Canada. I recommend the port of entry method—this means that you get all your paperwork together and show it at the Canadian border to get your work permit. It worked well for me, and the immigration lawyer also recommended it. (If you want the recommendation of the lawyer, feel free to reach out!)
More information here
Find Your Community Now — Or You’ll Regret It Later
I Sold My Rental and Changed Jobs to Save Myself
Learning How to Live in Canada
Speaking of kids, how do you pick schools and where to live? I loved the in-person feel for this if it's at all possible. Drive around. Meet people. See the schools. Walk the neighborhoods. Imagine your work-life balance. You know it’s the healthy choice. And why not if you are moving to a new country after all. Now is your chance to try it.
Of course, one can not write a column on moving to Canada without mentioning taxes. Taxes are high in Canada, and if you are moving (aka a settler), you can bring in your items tax-free one time. So, buy that pair of shoes now and take them with you to avoid the 15% sales tax! Also (if you can) sell your home before moving—the money you bring into Canada is not taxed the same as what you make once you're in Canada (or so I’m told).
Tip: If you decide to leave Canada before 18 months following your move, you won’t be taxed on additional investments in that time period.
OK, I have more I could share, but I think that is enough for today. I’ll post more in 2024 and share how my 2023 taxes turned out as I continue to make Canada my new home.
Have you moved to a different country as a physician? Was the process difficult? Are you happier now than you were as a US-based physician?
Moved to New Zealand in 2022 with my family. Got licensed. The process was a bit complicated with various steps and requirements. With training in US and my specialty it wasn’t a problem. There’s lots of things I like about practicing here, also lots of challenges too. Overall loving the more relaxed environment and culture of taking time off. Feels like a better balance than what I had in US even though I may be working more FTE currently.
Curious why you moved? What is the pay and lifestyle difference between NZ and the US?
Joy, awesome post and congrats on the move. How did the move affect your plans for retirement? Did you get well-versed in the retirement plans that are available in Canada? Are you keeping your US citizenship and are there any tax consequences for keeping the US citizenship in terms of your income in Canada?
I would be curious to know the answers to these questions as well!
Great article. Welcome to Canada. Navigating the parallel and chicken-egg regulatory bodies is tough for those trained here too. It is good to hear that they are finally loosening some of the restrictions.
-LD
Good luck. I’m American and spent 4 years working as a physician in Canada. For many reasons, we moved back to the US last year.
Good luck. I’m American and spent 4 years working as a physician in Canada. For many reasons, we moved back to the US last year.
As a born-, raised-, and trained- Canadian refugee physician to the US, this article is very cute. Naïve, but cute.
As a primary care physician, you trade the evils of the US healthcare system for the shortcomings and forced-evil of the public system. Critical lack of access caused by insurance companies is replaced by critical lack of access to specialized care. Unless maybe in Vancouver or Toronto or Calgary, where new physicians from the US would never be permitted to settle.
You fit right in here in the States with that level of bitterness and cynicism. You clearly don’t work with the rural poor.
I prefer the term “experienced”. The cynicism comes with the territory.
To be fair, I empathize with the joys of rural general practice, but the lack of support from the subspecialties is a devastating issue universally..
That is some top notch cynicism!
My wife (EM) got tired of being jerked around by insurance companies in WA so we moved to Canada to practice in Summer-2023. She got multiple offers to practice in Vancouver, and accepted work at two hospitals. No fuss, no restrictions on where she could practice EM, and our quality of life is much better (and slightly more expensive for that benefit).
Really? I tried to move to Squamish once to practice and was told I’d need to do two more years of residency to practice EM there.
If you’ve completed a 4-year residency and 1-year fellowship, you just have to write the Royal College exam and you can apply for your BC license. We have a friend from OR that took this route and started in EM in Vancouver at the same time in Summer-2023. No additional training required, just the annoying RCPSC exam.
Since COVID, BC (and ON) has also created a special license class for US trained physicians. 4-year US residency, ABEM certified, and some level of community practice and you can apply for a license. No additional training, and no need to sit the RCPSC exam. This is the route my wife took. From application to license to physically working in Vancouver was less than 6-months…..it took us longer to sell our house than it did to get licensed in BC.
No restrictions on where you can look for work, because they need EM docs in just about every community here at the moment. I will say that being a Canadian citizen (we are both dual) makes this move significantly easier!
Right. The issue was I did a 3 year residency, like most US emergency docs.
https://www.cpsbc.ca/registrants/current-registrants/registration-and-licensing/independent-practice/usa-certified
https://www.cpso.on.ca/en/Physicians/Registration/Registration-Policies/Alternative-Pathways-to-Registration
Note the requirements sections; I was technically wrong regarding BC – there’s nothing that specifies 4-year residency, just that you completed an ACGME residency and hold ABEM certification.
I wonder if that was different 20 years ago or if I got bad info back then.
Very different 20-years ago.
The BC “USA trained” license class was approved in Dec-2022, I think. My wife was one of the first applicants through the process.
The ON “Pathway A” approach isn’t more than ~5-years old.
I’m very interested in your experience with this and the Royal College exam(s). I applied to get approved to sit for the boards and practice in BC a few years ago (pre COVID actually) and I thought because I have had 5 years of training (1 year gen surg internship, 3 year EM, and a 1 year fellowship), I got a letter of approval to sit for the boards. I ended up not pursuing this (as of yet) mostly because I wasn’t totally convinced that it was a practical move for my family and also some lack of information about the board exams.
From what I could gather both the written boards and the oral boards appear to be somewhat or quite a bit more involved like short answer essay type questions on on the written boards regarding topics like specific named studies and their results. Anyway, despite having pretty solid confidence in my EM knowledge and US style test taking skills, it started looking like this might be a multi-thousand dollar investment and unclear how difficult or different this exam experience would be. Add that to not having a clear plan, but plenty of dreams of a life practicing medicine and enjoying the life in BC, made me not follow through at this point.
I’d also be curious if anyone does in fact know if this has changed so that folks who have traditionally trained with a 3 year residency now have more options to move and practice in Canada? I was just reading something about Nova Scotia and Ontario have lifted some barriers.
https://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/991400
Hello! My husband is canadian and we have been thinking of this for a long time. I am 6 years out of residency board certified OBGYN. I am licensed in NYS and California and were looking to get licensed in BC and ON (his fam is in ON)
any thoughts on how to get started? We are in california now. looking to be in city (toronto vancouver) not in rural practice
Amazing how much traffic this post has gotten this week! I wonder why and now there’s a comment on here.
I’m not sure the author is still following this comments thread but I guess we’ll see. I’m sorry I don’t know the answer to your question other than to say I looked into it once during residency when I visited Squamish to go climbing and thought it was paradise. At that time I was told I had to spend two extra years in residency if I wanted to come practice in Canada. I heard a while back that wasn’t true (or at least true anymore) though. Wish I had more info for you. I guess my first call if I were you would be to the medical board or its equivalent in BC or ON.
Jessica, if you want me to connect you with Joy, email me at [email protected]
Welcome to the Great North! There are bureaucracy and inefficiencies much like any system, we appreciate your contributions and hope you stay for a while
Thx for this super helpful post! How do we get in touch to ask you for info on lawyer contact details?!
You can send me an email at content (at) whitecoatinvestor.com, and I’ll get you in touch.
thx!
To the OP and whoever else is considering a move to Canada, you need to keep in mind that it is not simply like moving out of state. I was born, raised, educated, and trained in Canada before moving to the United States. There are different laws, financial system, culture, medical system and so on. It’s like moving to Europe, Australia or any other country: it’s a big deal. There are some significant issues that the OP failed to mention, the biggest one being tax compliance. The US and Eritrea are the only countries on Earth with citizenship-based taxation. If you move to Canada, you need to continue filing US tax returns. When you open Canadian bank accounts, you will need to declare those foreign accounts every year on your FBAR and another form on your tax return. If you open a corporation (LLCs don’t exist) to save on taxes, then you will be considered an owner of a foreign corporation by the IRS which will expose you to significant tax filing burdens and compliance. Your neighborhood CPAs in Canada or the US will be useless. You will need to hire a cross-border tax accountant every year to do this for you and you will pay a lot for it. If you decide not to form a corporation to save yourself the reporting headaches, the Canadian tax system will brutalize you. Moreover, you won’t be able to shield any of your Canadian income in any Canadian retirement accounts (RRSP) because the IRS won’t allow you to own mutual funds in those accounts and on an on. All of this requires significant due diligence if you don’t want to get in trouble with the IRS. One does not simply “move to Canada” unless you’re ready to play nice with the IRS. Immigration-wise, Canada lets everyone in, so that’s never an issue. Getting a license usually depends on you getting Canadian certification, but some provinces make exceptions if you have American BC.
Otherwise, the cost of living in Canada is insanely high, the taxes are punitive, real estate is equally expensive. The public schools are generally (albeit with exceptions) mediocre. In the US, if you live in a wealthy area, you generally have good schools. In Canada, education is funded mostly at the provincial level, so everyone gets the same mediocre-level schools. That’s equality. Everyone I know send their kids to private schools. Don’t forget woke politics, but I won’t get into that.
The healthcare system in Canada is government-run socialized medicine. The training of doctors is similar/identical to American training (in my opinion), but the facilities are analogous to the VA. Everything is rationed. Surgical waiting lists a year long is not unusual. Imaging? Not unusual to wait 4 months for a CT. I can go on. Here in the US, I get all the block time and instrumentation I need. I work in a small community hospital where having a DaVinci is not unusual. That would be unheard of in Canada.
I moved to the US ten years ago and it was one of the best decisions I ever made: low taxes, better weather, good schools for my kids, and an excellent quality of life. God bless America.
Yes G-d bless America and continue to bless America indeed! Great post!
Interesting that with all the negative attributes of the Canadian healthcare system, it still outperforms the US healthcare system on most all outcome measures.
https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/chart-collection/quality-u-s-healthcare-system-compare-countries/
– From a US Family Physician, working in a safety net system
Any physician with a knack for wading through rules and bureaucracy can make the move from the U.S. to Canada. Years ago the open door was to go to Newfoundland and tick off enough boxes with certifications, etc, to be able to move to Ontario. Most recently, as Canadian health metrics continue to spiral downward, U.S. board certification is accepted in Ontario, regardless of length of training, and without having to write any exams, AND you don’t need permanent residence. This is all relatively new. A little less new is that medicine also now falls under the Agreement on Internal Trade (AIT), allowing a physician registered in one province to be registered in another province, regardless of the rules of the other province.
There is a tendency for Americans to think Canada is “just like us,” and Canadians, being much more orderly and less obnoxious, don’t really refute that out of politeness. But the health systems are dramatically different; the professional role of a physician is dramatically different; and even what specialties exist in Canada, and the scope of that practice, is completely different. In many ways Canadian healthcare is more similar to the UK’s NHS. That “Royal” in Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada is from the patronage of King Charles, who is also King of Canada.
Decisions made regarding healthcare are made on a provincial level, with some decisions absolutely unfathomable in the U.S. Such as having no CT machine in more rural hospitals. Or a remote ER having difficulty staffing being “closed” for certain days. I’ve worked on both sides of the border, and if I had to be hospitalized it would be in the U.S., no question. Just some things to think about.
Thanks for sharing your experience.
I would love to pick your brain! What immigration lawyer did you use? Do you recommend them?
If you are a family physician interested in practicing in the Interior region of British Columbia, Canada, where there is a diversity of urban and rural options, please reach out to our network of non-profit recruiters who are eager to support you throughout the process, free of charge.
[Editor’s Note: If you wish to advertise here, contact cindy (at) whitecoatinvestor.com. Lots of opportunities available including personalized ones like an ad just on this post.]