Tampa Bay Insurance LLC DBA Tellico Lake Insurance

Introducing Tampa Bay Insurance LLC DBA Tellico Lake Insurance! With two decades of dedicated service, we pride ourselves on being your trusted family-owned insurance agency, serving residents across Florida, Tennessee, North Carolina, and Georgia. When you choose us, you're not just a policy number; you're a valued member of our extended family. We stand out in the industry for our unwavering commitment to exceptional customer service. At Tellico Lake Insurance, we're always just a phone call away, ready to address your insurance needs with a personal touch. Whether you're safeguarding your home, business, auto, or protecting against floods, we offer a wide array of tailored solutions. With our deep industry expertise and a vast network of reputable insurance partners, you can trust us to find the perfect coverage to fit your unique needs.

2402 Merchant Ave
Odessa FL 33556

(727) 372-5559

Why You?

What sets us apart is our unwavering commitment to delivering a truly exceptional insurance experience. As a family-owned agency with two decades of service under our belt, we embrace the values of trust, reliability, and personalized care. When you choose Tellico Lake Insurance, you're choosing more than just an insurance provider; you're becoming a valued member of our extended family. Our hallmark is the personal touch—we pick up the phone when you call, ensuring that your concerns are heard and your questions are answered. Our deep industry experience and wide array of company options mean that we can tailor coverage to your unique needs. With Tampa Bay Insurance LLC, you gain a dedicated partner who combines the warmth of a family business with the expertise and connections of an established industry player. Experience the difference for yourself, where exceptional customer service and a wide range of insurance solutions meet to safeguard what matters most to you.

Ideal Client

We welcome customers who appreciate the warmth and reliability of a family-owned agency with a 20-year legacy of excellence. If you value personalized service and want an insurance partner who listens to your needs, understands your concerns, and is always just a phone call away, you're our kind of client. Whether you reside in Florida, Tennessee, North Carolina, or Georgia, if you're seeking coverage for your home, auto, flood, umbrella, or business, we're here to serve you. Our ideal customers appreciate the wide array of options we offer and trust our seasoned industry expertise. If you desire not just an insurance policy but a trusted relationship, we invite you to become a part of our extended insurance family. Experience the difference that dedicated service and unmatched experience can make in securing your peace of mind.


D Stone
Wonderful experience and always professional. Carol has been our agent for several years now, we can always rely on her for accurate information! We love her attention to detail, her quick response, her wonderful and caring communication skills. A pleasure to do business with! We highly recommend Tampa Bay Insurance!!

Channing Lang
We have used Tampa Bay Insurance for the last 4 years and I cannot say enough about their professionalism, efficiency and the overall phenomenal job they do for our HVAC company and its insurance needs. Alex, Michelle and Darrin are a pleasure to work with and I cannot recommend them enough. If you need a solid, 5-star insurance advocate, call Tampa Bay Insurance LLC.

Tailored Twig
Michelle and her team have always taken amazing care of me and my business. Knowledgeable, efficient and kind. Their personal touch, and value placed on customer connection is refreshing in today's marketplace. We love supporting local people that are good humans, and the team at Tampa Bay Insurance exemplifies this. If you find yourself with insurance needs look no further – you've found the place.

Patti Ryan
Outstanding service from Tampa Bay Insurance LLC. They exceeded our expectations in every way. Their friendly and knowledgeable staff helped make sure we had the coverage we needed while saving us money on our home and auto policies. I can recommend them 100%.

Wanda Pillsbury
Absolutely the best rates stress-free experience that I’ve had in the past 40 years

Gary Sawicki
Andy is very knowledgeable and helpful. We now have more coverage for less cost.

Alison C Lynch
Thank goodness for Tampa Bay Insurance!
The professionals at Tampa Bay Insurance handle both my personal and my business insurance needs in a prompt, friendly & efficient manner. They are always solution oriented AND budget conscious. I’m busy running a small business and living an entrepreneurial lifestyle – I would have to learn an entire new industry just to understand my insurance requirements – that doesn’t even include managing it all. Michelle, Alex, and Teresa take care of everything! From answering my questions to filing forms and managing my workers comp – I could not run my small business without them. I highly recommend Tampa Bay insurance for all of your insurance needs. FIVE STARS!